Ethicon Surgical Staplers Recalled for Second Time After Injuries, Death Reported
In March 2019, the FDA reported more than 41,000 reports of stapler incidents dating back to 2011, finding 366 deaths, more than 9,000 serious injuries, and more than 32,000 malfunctions. It has issued a Class I recall, even as reports of injuries continue to appear.
What Are Surgical Staplers and How Do They Work?
Using staples in surgery is not a new method. Surgical staplers were introduced in 1908 by Hungarian surgeon Humer Hultl. They were brought to the U.S. more than fifty years later. The first American company to produce them was United States Surgical Corporation in 1964. Since then, other manufacturers have entered the business, including Johnson & Johnson under the Ethicon brand.
They are designed to suture, connect, or seal tissue using metal staples that are formed by the stapler where the surgeon desires. Essentially, there are two classes of staplers – disposable and non-disposable. There are three styles of staples that can be created by different staplers, depending on the type of connection required by the procedure. Those are straight, curved, or circular. The staples are made of metal, either stainless steel or titanium, and have to be removed at some point. Plastic staples are also used, and there are staples made of polylactide-polyglycolide copolymer that are designed to be absorbed into the body.
The signs of a misfired or malformed staple may not occur for several days after the procedure. They’re typically used in procedures such as:
- Gastrointestinal Surgery
- Gastric Bypass Surgery (Stomach Stapling)
- Bowel Surgery
- Lung Surgery
- Thoracic Surgery (Neck Related)
- Cardiovascular Surgery (Heart Related)
How Do Ethicon Staplers Fail?
The Ethicon Flex Endopath models in the latest recall are the disposable type, intended for use in one single operation and use metal staples. In their reasoning for the Class I recall – the most urgent type of recall, as it involves the risk of patient harm or even death – the FDA stated that the recalled devices contain an out-of-specification part within the jaw of the device that can cause staples to be malformed.
Malformed staples, in turn, can lead to serious consequences for patients, including:
- Prolonged surgeries
- Postoperative connection (anastomotic) leaks
- Hemorrhagic shock
- Additional surgeries to correct or intervene
There have been seven injuries reported and one death reported leading up to this latest recall. It is the second recall of Ethicon brand staplers in the last two years. The current recall affects 8,256 of the following models and batch numbers distributed between August 1 and September 26, 2019:
- Flex 60 Endopath Stapler, Articulating Endoscopic Linear Cutter, product code EC60A, lot Nos. T9408M and T94A9Z.
- Flex 60 Powered Plus Compact Articulating Endoscopic Linear Cutter, product code PCEE60A, lot Nos. T93Z9Y and T9411A.
- Flex 60 Powered Plus Articulating Endoscopic Linear Cutter, 44cm Shaft Length, product code PLEE60A, lot Nos. T93X95; T93Z75; T93Z2W; T9413Z; T93Z1G; T93Y4M; T94045; T94117; T93X17; T94087; T93Z2X; T9405L; and T94253
- Flex 60 Powered Plus Articulating Endoscopic Linear Cutter, 34cm Shaft Length, product code PSEE60A, lot Nos. T93Z5W; T93Z5X; T9405V; T9405W; T93Z3F; T9401L; T93Y8X; T94008; T9400D; T93Z5R.
A History of Harm: Previous Ethicon Recall
The October 2019 recall from the FDA is disturbing, but it is sadly not new for Ethicon. In May 2019, the FDA issued a Class I recall for several of their Curved Intraluminal Staplers. Investigation after complaints revealed that some products contained uncut washers and a firing issue that caused malformed staples.
This was attributed to a change in the manufacturing process that was introduced in March of 2018 and continued through March of 2019. This prompted a recall of 92,496 of the following products distributed between March 15, 2018, and March 8, 2019:
- Endo-Surgery Curved Intraluminal Stapler with Adjustable Height Staples
- Endo-Surgery Endoscopic Curved Intraluminal Stapler with Adjustable Height Staples
- Product Codes: CDH21A, CDH25A, CDH29A, CDH33A, ECS21A, ECS25A, ECS29A, ECS33A
In that recall, the FDA recommended that surgeons use manual staplers from other manufacturers, hand-sew closures, use minimally invasive techniques where possible, or delay surgeries where the staplers’ use was necessary. The staplers had been used in a variety of operations on patients, and their failures produced a wide range of serious injuries and side effects, including:
- Bacterial infection
- Need for lifelong ostomy “bag”
- Lifelong nutritional and digestive issues
- Anastomotic leaks
- Need for additional surgeries or closures
- Need for antibiotics and/or additional imaging studies
Tightening FDA Approval Requirements – Too Little Too Late?
ECRI, an independent, non-profit patient safety organization, placed surgical staplers at the top of its list of health technology hazards in October 2019. This after the FDA proposed, in April 2019, reclassifying surgical staplers from Class I to Class II.
Class I devices are not heavily tested or regulated and do not undergo premarket review, and include things like cotton swabs and crutches. Class II devices must undergo a premarket review by the FDA before being approved for use.
Manufacturers claim that they treat staplers as Class II devices, even though the FDA does not perform premarket reviews on them. The FDA has already classified implantable surgical staples as the more regulated and tested Class II devices. Oddly, the staplers themselves have remained Class I.
However, the move toward additional regulation came after a review of the FDA’s internal database and the alternative medical reporting system for instances occurring between January 1, 2011, and December 31, 2018. The agency has noted that its reliance on manufacturers, physicians, and other voluntary reporters to record malfunctions is “imperfect.”
The databases contained records on approximately 110,000 malfunctions, and 422 deaths. As previously noted, surgical staplers have been in use for decades. For this many malfunctions to be reported – and perhaps underreported – in just eight years is mind-boggling.
If You Were Hurt or Suffered Complications Due to Defective Surgical Staplers, We May Be Able to Help
Whether your procedure was routine or emergency, you have every right to expect that the products used to treat you will function properly. When those products fail, the consequences can be catastrophic. Suddenly, a procedure that was supposed to bring you relief only brings you grief.
If you or a loved one has suffered or is suffering the effects of a malformed surgical staple, call the Law Offices of James Scott Farrin at 1-866-900-7078 for a free case evaluation, or contact us online.