NC Workers’ Comp Settlements: Proceed With Caution

At some point, most injured workers receive a phone call from the workers’ compensation insurance company asking whether they’re ready to settle their case. Maybe you’ve already received that call…

If so, it’s probably a good time to consult a James Scott Farrin workers’ compensation attorney. More than half our workers’ comp attorneys are NC State Bar Board Certified Specialists in Workers’ Compensation law. This is the highest level of specialization available in N.C., and only a small percentage of N.C. attorneys can make that claim. Very small.

Navigating the twists and turns of the North Carolina workers’ compensation system is hard enough while your case is still open. But when you receive that phone call, you’ve got a whole new set of issues to consider. This is your livelihood we’re talking about. You don’t want to make any decisions you later regret. And when it comes to determining the “value” of your case, Facebook said it best: it’s complicated!

It is important to know that not all workers’ compensation cases settle. Having an attorney guide you through the process of your case can help you in many ways. Call our office today at 1-866-900-7078.

Do All Workers’ Comp Cases Settle?

First thing’s first. It’s important for every injured worker in North Carolina to understand that not all workers’ compensation cases settle. There is no requirement that your case should eventually settle, and you can’t force a workers’ compensation insurance company to offer a settlement. In fact, based on my experience, some injured workers are better off leaving their cases open.

What Is a Workers’ Comp “Clincher” Agreement?

Many workers’ compensation cases do eventually resolve by “clincher” agreement. This means the insurance company offers a lump sum of money to an injured worker in return for a full and final settlement of their case. A clincher (or settlement agreement) typically closes the case in full, including all medical treatment and wage replacement benefits.

Before taking a settlement for your workers' comp injury from insurance, consult with a workers' comp lawyer.

If you find yourself considering a settlement, BE CAREFUL! Before making any big decisions, there are two important issues you should examine.

Is It a Good Time To Settle Your Case?

I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again: Every workers’ compensation case is different. Based on my opinion, however, for most cases, the best time to settle is after your major medical treatment has concluded. If the insurance company pushes you toward a settlement too quickly, they may be unable to reasonably evaluate the value of your case. This can result in lowball settlement offers, which typically do more harm than good.

Additionally, there are many other benefits you may or may not be receiving, which can adversely affect (or be adversely affected by) potential workers’ compensation settlement results in North Carolina. Social Security Disability benefits, Medicare, Medicaid, and even private disability/health insurance plans can cause complicated legal issues when it comes time to settle your workers’ compensation case. All of these issues must be carefully considered in order to determine whether settlement is a good idea, based on your particular set of circumstances.

What Is the “Value” of Your Workers’ Comp Case?

Once you decide it’s a good time to settle your case, there’s still another looming question that will need to be answered: How much?

My job as a workers’ compensation attorney would be a lot easier if there was a magic “settlement calculator,” but unfortunately, it doesn’t exist. In order to determine the reasonable value of your claim, an experienced professional will typically consider the following:

    • The cost of your future medical treatment


    • The likelihood that your injury will prevent you from returning to work in some capacity down the road


    • Any decreased earning potential resulting from your injury


Additionally, you may be entitled to an award for a permanent partial disability rating to your injured body part or parts. This is typically determined by your doctor. The calculation associated with this potential award is set by statute in North Carolina.

James Scott Farrin workers’ comp attorneys are trained to help you weigh the pros and cons of settling your case. If you decide to move forward with settlement, your attorney can then help you negotiate with the insurance company in order to try to maximize the amount you could potentially receive. Regardless of whether or not you decide to retain an attorney, when it comes to workers’ compensation claim settlements, proceed with caution.

What Happens When My Workers’ Comp Case Is Closed?

If you settle your workers’ comp case, the insurance company has fulfilled its responsibility – in other words, it generally no longer needs to pay for any future medical costs associated with your work-related injury.

It is important for you to be confident that any settlement that you agree to provides you with the benefits that you would likely receive if you established your claim and kept the case open – such as compensation for lost wages, any permanent injuries, and medical care. Because when your workers’ comp case is closed, you will no longer receive these benefits from the insurance company.

North Carolina Workers’ Comp Lawyers Offer FREE Case Evaluation

Workers’ comp is complicated to navigate. We urge you to consult with us if you have any questions whatsoever.

If you think you can’t afford a workers’ comp lawyer, you may be surprised. Our attorneys work on a contingency fee basis, which means we’re no win no attorney’s fee workers’ compensation lawyers. This allows us to try to help our clients navigate the best course of action for their unique situation.2

Feel free to contact us or call us toll-free at 1-866-900-7078We’ll have an attorney evaluate your case for FREE.

Text UsText Us

You May Also Be Interested In

Should I Negotiate My Own Workers’ Comp Settlement in NC?

How Do Settlements Work in Workers’ Compensation Cases?

Can My Worker’s Compensation Insurance Company Force Me to Settle?

Types of Workers’ Compensation Benefits in North Carolina

About the Author

Ryan Bliss is a workers’ compensation attorney in North Carolina and co-leader of the Workers’ Compensation Department at the Law Offices of James Scott Farrin. Ryan is one of fewer than 200 North Carolina State Bar Board Certified Specialists in Workers’ Compensation Law.a He was named a “Rising Star”b by Super Lawyers Magazine in 2018 and wrote an article called “Workers’ Compensation for the Undocumented Worker” for Trial Briefs Magazine in January 2018.

aNumbers provided by NC State Bar as of 2/21.

bFor more information regarding standards of inclusion, please visit